houghton logo

Test Data
Case Studies
Back to our home page


waterfrontlogo


General Product Information

Belclene 200 has been developed as a calcium carbonate inhibitor in industrial water systems and other related applications.

The active ingredient of Belclene 200 is polymaleic acid. The CAS number is 26099-09-2
Typical physical properties
appearance      clear amber liquid
odour slight
solids content 47-53% w/w
specific gravity 1.16-1.19
pH (undiluted) < 2
viscosity at 25°C 12-30 cPs (10-25 cSt)
boiling point range 100-102°C (212-214°F)
freeze point range -5 to -12°C (10-23°F)
solubility
     in water
     ethylene glycol
     methanol
     50% caustic soda

miscible
miscible
miscible
readily neutralised with the evolution of heat
steam volatility does not steam distil
pH limitations to avoid precipitation, formulate below pH 2.5 or above pH 8.0. At in use concentrations Belclene 200 is stable at any pH.

Thermal stability (TGA)
Thermogravimetric analysis has shown that Belclene 200 is stable up to a temperature of 300°C (572°F).

Chemical reactivity/compatibility
Belclene 200 is not affected by chlorine or other oxidising biocides under normal use conditions. Test for compatibility with long chain nitrogen compounds. aliphatic amine and quaternary ammonium compounds.
Logistics
classification      irritant for supply
corrosive for conveyance
IATA class 8 UN No 1760
IMCO class 8 UN No 1760
packaging HDPE 220L XL-ring Mauser drum
height 935 mm
diameter 580 mm
gross weight 249.5 kg
net weight 240.0 kg

Regulatory approvals
FDA (USA)      21 cfr 173.310 - boiler additives
21 cfr 173.45 - beet and cane sugar
21 cfr 573 - poultry watering systems
USDA (USA) G5: cooling and retort water
G6: boilers, steamlines possible food contact
G7: boilers, stearnlines, cooling systems no food contact
A1: clewing compounds: meat/poultry plants
MITI (Japan) Japanese discharge regulations

Toxicology data
acute oral LD50 (rats)      >5000 mg/kg
eye irritation (rabbits) irritant (EEC guidelines)
skin irritation (rabbits) non-irritant (EEC guidelines)
toxicity to fish
     98-hr LC50 (rainbow trout)
     96-hr LC50 (carp)

>100 mg/l
>100 mg/l


Ecological data
96-hr LC50 (brown shrimp) 580 mg/l
48-hr LC50 (daphnia magna) >1000 mg/l
48-hr LC50 (sludge inhibition)      >1000 mg/l
COD 1199mg O2/g
TOC 1050mg O2/g
biodegradability 18% in 35 days (OECD 302B screening test)

Further details on safety and handling are available in the material safety data sheet on this product.


The industry standard for calcium carbonate control in stressed water conditions


New test data confirms that Belclene® 200 is the most effective antiscalant for calcium carbonate under severe service conditions

Practical experience has shown that Belclene 200 antiscalant is the most effective calcium carbonate scale inhibitor for severe service conditions. Belclene 200 is widely used in many proprietary formulations and is in use in thousands of systems worldwide.

New research carried out at FMC's Trafford Park Laboratories has confirmed this experience in direct comparison with alternative chemical inhibitors.

An experimental pilot cooling tower (PCT) was used as shown in figure 1. The PCT was run continuously with zero blowdown to increase the cycles of concentration. Heat transfer was monitored continuously and the water analysed at regular intervals. A loss of more than 10% of the soluble calcium was taken to indicate polymer failure. The results are shown graphically in figure 2. The results prove conclusively that Belclene 200 will stabilise calcium carbonate more effectively than other available chemical inhibitors in severe service applications, and maintains performance at Langelier scaling index of up to 3.3.

Benefits to the customer

  • Belclene 200 conforms to ISO 9000 quality procedures. Customers can therefore expect a quality product which is easily formulated into proprietary products and which is readily available.

  • Belclene 200 provides cost-effective calcium carbonate scale control. It is particularly effective in high hardness conditions.

  • Belclene 200 helps to maintain heat transfer rates, thus reducing energy costs and extending plant operation for the end user.

It is therefore simple to demonstrate a positive payback on treatment cost to the end user.

Figure 1: Recirculating water pilot cooling tower

figure1.JPG (15095 bytes)


Figure 2: Inhibition of calcium carbonate In the pilot cooling tower

figure2.JPG (32478 bytes)
Starting water conditions:
Ca2+      250 ppm as CaCO3
Mg2+ 121 ppm as CaCO3
CO33- 57 ppm as CaCO3
HCO32- 295 ppm as CaCO3
pH 8.8
bulk solution temperature 40°C
heat exchanger surface temperature 70°C

heat exchanger
    
stainless steel
metallurgy cycle time about 24 hours
Additive dosage 20 ppm as active ingredient

Langelier scaling Index at failure point:
Belclene 200      3.3 (850 ppm as CaCO3)
PAA (molecular weight 2000) 3.1 (645 ppm as CaCO3)
AMPS/acrylic 2.7 (363 ppm as CaCO3)



Case histories in sugar mill evaporators

Summary
Belclene® 200 antiscalant has been shown to be extremely effective as a scale inhibitor in two cane sugar mill evaporators. The use of Belclene 200 at 8 mg/l (product) enables the mills to extend the length of time between evaporator cleanings and substantially reduce the amount of chemicals required for such cleaning. The use of Belclene 200 has increased sugar, molasses, and energy production resulting in significant economic benefits at both mills.

Introduction
Owing to its outstanding performance in inhibiting the mixed scales found in sugar evaporators, Belclene 200 has gained strong acceptance as part of formulations to treat scale in both cane and beet sugar processes. Utilising formulations based on Belclene 200 can significantly improve scale inhibition, resulting in reduced down time for cleaning, higher mill productivity, and reduced cleaning chemical usage, Belclene 200 has FDA clearance for use in beet and cane sugar (21 cfr 173.45).

Deposits found in sugar evaporators often contain a mixture of inorganic scale species which can include:
     - calcium carbonate
     - calcium phosphate
     - calcium oxalate
     - calcium silicate
     - calcium sulphate

Sugar mill evaporators often require frequent cleaning, causing lengthy shut downs, which reduce production and incur significant cleaning chemical expense. Belclene 200 has been found to be excellent at controlling such mixed scales, and the high thermal stability of Belclene 200 makes it ideal for use at the high temperatures experienced in sugar evaporator systems. The following case histories are taken from successful trials of Belclene 200 at two cane sugar mills in Latin America.

Case history 1

Prior to the addition of Belclene 200:
Milling capacity      11000 tonnes/day
Production rate 95 kg sugar/tonne ground cane
Scale characteristics calcium phosphate, calcium sulphate, calcium carbonate, silicate
Total hardness (clarified juice) 1200 mg/l as CaCO3
Cleaning cycle 6 days
Scale thickness (prior to cleaning) 0.8 mm - 1.6 mm hard scale
Cleaning time 14-24 hours (750 kg sulphamic acid, 14000 litres sodium hydroxide)

With Belclene 200:
Dosage rate      8 mg/l of Belclene 200 (product) to clarified juice
Scale thickness 0-0.4 mm soft scale
Cleaning time 8-12 hours (300 kg sulphamic acid, 5500 litres sodium hydroxide)

Results
The use of 8 mg/l of Belclene 200:
     - reduced scale thickness by over 50%
     - reduced the total amount of cleaning chemicals required by 60%.
     - reduced the number of hours downtime for each clean by 50%.

Case history 2

Prior to the addition of Belclene 200:
Milling capacity      3000 tonnes/day
Production rate 95 kg sugar/tonne ground cane
Flow of clarified juice 460 tonnes/day
Scale characteristics calcium phosphate, calcium sulphate, calcium carbonate, calcium silicate
Total hardness (clarified juice) 800 ppm as CaCO3
Cleaning cycle 9 days
Scale thickness (prior to cleaning) 0.8 mm - 1.6 mm hard scale
Cleaning time 14-24 hours (400 litres HCl, 300 kg Na2CO3, 400 litres NaOH, activators)

With Belclene 200:
Dosage Rate      8 mg/l of Belclene 200 (product) to clarified juice
Cleaning cycle 14 days
Scale thickness 0.4 mm - 0.8 mm soft scale
Cleaning time 10-14 hours (220 litres HCl, 150 kg Na2CO3, 400 litres NaOH, activators)

Results
The use of Belclene 200 antiscalant:
     - enabled the mill to extend time between shutdowns for cleaning by 55%
     - reduced scale thickness by 50%
     - reduced the total amount of cleaning chemicals required by 60%
     - reduced the number of hours downtime for each clean by approximately 30%.

Conclusions
Belclene 200 has been proved to be a very effective antiscalant for sugar mill evaporators at an additive rate of 8 ppm (product).

By reducing the downtime required to clean evaporators, the use of Belclene 200 helped to increase the production of sugar, molasses, and energy by up to 10%, resulting in significant economic benefits for both mills.

Any scale formed in the presence of Belclene 200 is softer and easier to remove requiring decreased chemical usage and less time for cleaning.


fmc logoProcess Additives Division


Warranty - Patent Position
The information contained herein is, to our knowledge, true and accurate. Because conditions of use are beyond our control, we make no warranty or representation, express or implied. except that the products discussed herein conform to the chemical descriptions shown on the labels. Nothing contained herein should be construed as permission or recommendation to infringe any patent. No agent, representative or employee of this company is authorised to vary any terms of this notice.



[Home]

E-Mail Us

The following are trademarks of FMC Corporation: Belclene, FMC logo, Waterfront logo
®Registered US Patent and Trademark Office
©1993, 1994 FMC Corporation
All rights reserved